Jonathan Franzen bemoans Bad Sex nomination for ‘protruding pencil of tenderness’

“It’s always weird talking about sex in my books in England because I feel like there’s a particularly harsh measure of what’s OK to write about and what’s not,” he said.

His bestseller, Freedom, was nominated for the Literary Review’s Bad Sex in Fiction Award in 2010, a decision that still rankles.

“The Bad Sex Award is an English award, right?” he asked. “What was wrong with what I wrote? I don’t get it.”

At the time, the Literary Review noted Franzen’s “propensity for innuendo which comes over a bit Benny Hill”.

The passage which caught their attention included Franzen referring to “a protruding pencil of tenderness”.

His interviewer at the Cheltenham Literature Festival, the writer Clare Clark, did not provide much consolation when she told him that being nominated for the Bad Sex Award was “a twisted English compliment…they only award it to people who are good enough writers to know better.”

Franzen said Clark had not offered him “a pathway to feeling ok about it”.

‘Our vocabulary is so impoverished, and you either end up being pornographic or sugary sweet’

Defending his sex scenes, he said: “Sex is a big part of people’s lives, particularly young people. I can’t just draw a curtain over it because how a particular moment of sex plays out is important.

“I know for myself that I have memories of those moments and they’ve stayed with me because they were sometimes great, sometimes terrible, sometimes super-awkward, sometimes remarkably not awkward.

“In every case, I remember it vividly and I wouldn’t want to simply close off that part of what a person experiences or remembers because it might make someone uncomfortable to read about it.”

Also at the festival, Sebastian Faulks discussed the awkwardness of sex, which he said was “traditionally thought to be impossible because our vocabulary is so impoverished, and you either end up being pornographic or sugary sweet.

“The fact it’s so difficult doesn’t mean you shouldn’t try, although of course, in the back of your mind, there’s always the Literary Review’s Bad Sex prize.

“One of the things I learned, thinking about this years ago, was that there’s no point in describing two people making love because everyone knows what happens. The only reason to go into any detail at all is if something is disclosed between the two people.”

Franzen, during an interview conducted via videolink from the US, also discussed the thorny topic of white privilege.

“In fairness, I’m a privileged white male writer and it is past time to be questioning in a serious way, collectively, what that privilege means.

“It doesn’t feel that way to me personally because I just grew up leading my life, but I have reached a position of visibility that makes me able to understand why people would look at me as a symbol of that kind of privilege,” he said.

When writing non-white characters, white authors should ask themselves if they were doing it with appropriate sensitivity, Franzen said, but he added a warning.

“I do think for white Americans it is incumbent on us to be careful, and to really look hard and think hard about what we are doing when we render non-white characters.

“But obviously you can’t restrict writers to only writing about characters close to themselves, because it’s a recipe for the death of fiction,” he said.

Related Posts

Josh Hartnett as a maniac: the trailer for M. Night Shyamalan’s new film “Trap” has been released

The film is due to be released in Ukrainian on August 8, 2024. The main role in “West” was played by Josh Hartnett / screenshot from YouTube…

Aliens may actually be purple, not green, say scientists

Green is a common color on Earth, but on other planets with different living conditions things may be different. Aliens may have a rather exotic color /…

The former US vice president is confident that if he wins in Ukraine, Putin will strike at NATO

After the victory in Ukraine, Putin will not stop, Pence is sure. Pence has no doubt that Putin will attack NATO / photo ua.depositphotos.com Former US Vice…

In the Krynok area the enemy has significantly intensified attacks: what are the consequences of the assaults

Together with the Strela air defense system and artillery systems, the invaders lost more than 90 bayonets. It became known what was happening on the southern front…

It became known what hit the Dnieper: the number of victims has increased (photo report)

According to updated data, five more high-rise buildings, two private houses and three educational institutions were damaged. Russia hit the Dnieper / photo The number of victims…

Nagelsmann decided to remain as head coach of the German national football team

The specialist will lead the team to the home European Football Championship. Julian Nagelsmann will remain with the German national football team / photo REUTERS Julian Nagelsmann…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *