Rise of the nanny state puts small state Conservatism under threat

But slashing back the state is no easy task. Health spending as a share of GDP alone has risen from 4pc of GDP to above 7pc in the past 40 years, and is predicted to reach 8.4pc by 2025. Meanwhile state pension spending of £105bn this year could reach £133bn by the middle of the decade.

Despite the splurge, Brexit minister Lord Frost made the case for a low tax, lightly regulated economy at the Centre for Policy Studies this week.

Last year, rising cabinet star Liz Truss also asked Thatcher’s favourite thinktank to come up with ways of rolling back the state, and it devised a £30bn menu of nine options including public land sell-offs. But with the PM against austerity, sources mutter little has been done even on this small change – in fiscal terms at least – as ministers “need to be willing to upset people”.

Paul Johnson, director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, says turning the clock back to Thatcher would only be possible with “a quite different settlement” on public services such as leaving “a fraction of the population to pay for their own health care, or some large chunk of it, for instance”. Rooting out inefficiencies in the existing framework simply isn’t enough.

The economist points out that Thatcher’s revolution focused on wholesale privatisations rather than cuts to public services, which were deeper under the Coalition between 2010 and 2017. “The obvious difference between the Thatcher years and now is that focus on the market, the movement of the state out of areas.”

That contrasts with the Government’s stated ambitions on infrastructure as Johnson flags up major increases in capital spending underlined by the latest £96bn rail plans. “If I was asked to bet, my bet would be that tax and spending will be higher as a fraction of GDP in 10 years’ time than it is today,” says Johnson.

Tees Valley mayor Ben Houchen, another influential Conservative figure who is leading a major regeneration project on Teesside, argues fears over a creeping public sector are based on a “misunderstanding” and the UK would lose out in emerging industries by standing aside, as interventionist rivals tempt mobile global capital.

“It’s about using the state to leverage private sector investment. That doesn’t mean the state needs to be bigger, just smarter,” he says. “You can have a savvy commercially aware Government that unlocks investment and jobs without it being big and bureaucratic, and often it’s not about more spending, but clever and cleaner regulation to incentivise business to the UK.”

But there has been little sign of that strategic thinking so far from a Government beset by the pandemic and far too willing to turn to tax and spend, according to its critics.

Tice says: “It’s a bit like water going over a waterfall. Once you get so far, you can’t stop it. I think we’ve got less than five years beyond which continual tax rises and wasteful spending become endemic.

“If it goes so far, you’ve actually become a boring European social democracy. And then, frankly, as a dynamic high-growth nation, the place is finished. It’s done, it’s gone.”

The party will likely watch the by-election with eager eyes this week, as an indicator of public support towards a high-stakes debate that will shape the British economy for years to come.

Related Posts

We praise the affable father and great leader: the DPRK created an anthem for Kim Jong-un (video)

The move is part of efforts to strengthen Kim’s position. A video for a song about Kim Jong-un was shown on Korean state television / screenshot North…

There are more scammers in Ukraine: the number of cases has broken a 12-year record

On average, 8 thousand cases are opened per month this year. A record number of fraud cases have been opened in Ukraine / photo In the first…

Scientists have named a drink that helps fight obesity, tooth decay and diabetes

Nutritionist Abby Sharp has some advice on which juice is best for your health. Cranberries are very beneficial for the body / photo ua.depositphotos.com Scientists have discovered…

Without sensations: it became known who will play in the semi-finals of the Conference League

In two matches at once, the semi-finalists were determined in a penalty shootout. The first matches of the Conference League semi-finals will take place on May 2…

China preparing to physically destroy US critical infrastructure, FBI Director

To do this, China plans to use its hacker group, which has already penetrated the computer networks of US infrastructure companies, the FBI says. FBI Director Christopher…

GUR: The enemy has not given up massive missile attacks, weapons are being accumulated

Ukraine is preparing retaliatory measures. The occupiers did not abandon massive missile attacks / screenshot The aggressor country has not given up carrying out massive missile attacks…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *