Someone needs to tell Peter Jackson and the makers of James Bond to read Lord of the Flies

Of course, editing isn’t just about adjusting length. Thoughtful editing can often transform a work, rescuing it from the slush pile and turning it into a gleaming masterpiece. In the early 1960s, William Golding’s Lord of the Flies was rejected by several publishers. It took a savvy and thoughtful editor – Charles Monteith of Faber and Faber – to recognise the potential in this strange tale of a group of schoolboys who attempt, disastrously, to impose a sort of self-government when their plane crash-lands on a desert island. 

Out went the odd conversation with a lone figure who might or might not have been God, while the character of Simon was heavily redacted. Golding may have been bruised by the experience, but Monteith made sure he had his name on a piece of literature that is now considered totemic.

“More a series of anecdotes than a fully conceived novel,” said American literary editor Tay Hohoff of Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird when it was first submitted. Many drafts later, and Hohoff and Lee had collaborated to create a novel that is tight, fast-moving, and incredibly powerful in some of its epigrammatic statements. When an early draft of Mockingbird, Go Set a Watchman, was released in 2015, Hohoff’s granddaughter criticised the light edit, when she knew the painstaking process which had produced Lee’s masterpiece.

Editors in all artistic forms are there for a reason, and everyone working in the creative industries needs to realise that an unfiltered version of any work results in bad art (or at least less good art). Yes, creativity is often subjective, but a good editor can get into a good artist’s head, and if they can’t, then the artist should go back to the drawing board.

And just to add, if I have banged on for far too long then I’m very sorry. Hopefully, my judicious editor will cut this bit out.

Related Posts

Today in Kyiv it will become a couple of degrees warmer

But it will rain again in the capital on April 16. It will rain in Kyiv on April 16 / photo Kev, Pixabay On Tuesday, April 16,…

Russia’s losses are growing – the Ukrainian Armed Forces eliminated more than 900 invaders per day – General Staff

The defense forces destroyed 13 armored fighting vehicles, 16 artillery systems and 9 tanks. The Ukrainian Armed Forces are eliminating the enemy / photo 95 separate air…

Horoscope for April 16: Pisces – new opportunities, Aquarius – difficult challenges

The day promises changes in the lives of some zodiac signs. Horoscope for April 16 / photo ua.depositphotos.com Astrologers have compiled a horoscope for April 16 for…

A well-known weather forecaster warns of sleet and frost in Ukraine

Frosts, according to Natalya Didenko, are possible in the second half of this week. It will be quite cool in Ukraine in the coming days / photo…

Dividing US aid to Ukraine and Israel: WSJ revealed details of Johnson’s plan

The Speaker of the House of Representatives expects to complete voting on the bills this week, journalists have found out. Details of Mike Johnson’s plan to help…

More than 100 clashes per day: the General Staff spoke about the situation at the front

Over the past 24 hours, aviation of the Ukrainian Defense Forces destroyed the enemy’s control center. There are tough battles at the front / photo of the…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *