Many blame Covid for the “disconnect” between the current crop of new MPs and their whips, with lockdown restrictions having put paid to the face-to-face interaction they might have expected upon entering Parliament two years ago. “There’s very little esprit de corps in the House,” admitted one backbencher.
Social media has also “changed everything”, according to one former whip. “The days a whip could lift an MP off their feet by his tie and start squeezing his testicles are over,” they said.
“You’d end up in prison if you tried that today – and rightly so – but these days MPs are very much in control of their own messaging. Also, a lot of these newer MPs come from professional backgrounds. They’ve had jobs outside politics and they are not going to put up with any nonsense that wouldn’t stand up to scrutiny in a corporate HR department.”
Another problem is the slow creep of Downing Street control over its own whipping operation, which set in under David Cameron. “The whips’ office should be a conduit to Number 10 to tell them what MPs are thinking, but it’s become a conduit for Number 10 to tell MPs what to think,” the former whip added.
“Whoever it was in Downing Street who decided to describe the 2019 intake as ‘nobodies’ needs their head read.”
The “lack of love” shown to Tories this week struggling with the dilemma of wanting to support Mr Johnson while having to fend off “irate” emails from constituents and “incandescent” associations has only served to push some newer MPs further away.
“I won’t be consulting with my whip in future – I’ll just speak to the ‘grey hairs’, which will include people like David Davis, who has called for Boris to go,” warned one backbencher.
Or as another put it: “A lot of these newer MPs weren’t expected to win their seats. They should have been treated with extra care, not left to get on with it.
“The chaos in the whips’ office is an extension of the chaos in Number 10. When you’ve got an administration that is both incompetent and arrogant, this is the result.”