Ed Sheeran has done no wrong – copyright lawsuits are ruining modern pop

In the case of Shape of You, it all centres on a brief but repeated melodic snippet in which Switch sings “Why oh why oh why oh why” and Sheeran sings “I oh I oh I oh.” Sheeran’s defence (and I think it’s a good one) is that he had never heard of Switch, and therefore any similarity is entirely coincidental. Much has been made of the fact that he settled a multimillion pound lawsuit on his 2015 song Photograph, brought by the composers of an earlier song, Amazing, performed by X Factor winner Matt Cardle. 

In court, Sheeran claimed to have been “bruised” by that experience. “Even though I felt that I had done nothing wrong, we decided to settle the case because of the money and time it would take to fight it. However, that left me with a very bad feeling afterwards. The decision to settle felt morally weird given that we were innocent of the allegations made. It made me feel like I did not want to play the song anymore.”

That line really struck a chord with me. The weaponisation of lawsuits to claim part ownership of copyright of big hits (because, let’s face it, nobody sues for a share of a flop) threatens the creative freedom needed to actually make music.

There are only 12 notes in a scale, and there are strongly established formats for chord sequences and song patterns. Songwriters are constantly mimicking, repeating and building on what other songwriters have done, sometimes consciously, often subconsciously. 

As that great rock’n’roll sage Keith Richards once said, “There’s only one song, and Adam and Eve wrote it; the rest is variation”. From primitive man’s drumbeats in the prehistoric savannah to the techno throb banging out of your local high street disco, every song is related to every other song in some essential respects, passed along a chain of musician, each briefly lending their own talents only for the music itself to be passed along again.

Related Posts

the court deprived the mayor of chernigov of the right

The court deprived the mayor of Chernigov of the right to hold a state position – NAKC for one year

The court found the mayor guilty of an administrative offense: in addition to depriving him of the right to hold office, he ordered 6.8 thousand hryvnias. fine…

zelenskyi told how many settlements have already been liberated by

Zelenskyi told how many settlements have already been liberated by the Armed Forces of Ukraine and how many still remain

The President stressed that Ukraine has no right to leave any of its people in Russian occupation and Russian infiltration camps. Zelensky called the war in Ukraine…

caught in a landmine trap a group of policemen was

Caught in a landmine trap: a group of policemen was blown up in the Kherson region (photo)

Four more police officers are in the hospital. Doctors are fighting for their lives. A group of policemen died in Kherson Oblast \ photo by In the…

it is absolutely impossible to raise the tariff for the

It is absolutely impossible to raise the tariff for the transmission and dispatch of electricity during the war – the head of the association of entrepreneurs

Illustration by REUTERS The increase in tariffs for transmission and dispatching of electricity, which is initiated by the energy regulator NERCU, will be a devastating blow to…

in odesa district water supply has been restored in almost

In Odesa district, water supply has been restored in almost all communities

The water disappeared in the area due to a rocket strike by the enemy on December 5. Water was given in Odesa district / photo Water supply…

the pope compared the actions of the kremlin in ukraine

The Pope compared the actions of the Kremlin in Ukraine with the actions of Nazi Germany

He emphasized that history is repeating itself today. The Pope again mentioned the war in Ukraine photo by REUTERS During the general audience, Pope Francis again recalled…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *