The Covid Inquiry must remember that the victims are not only the ones who died from it

Hang on, what happened to the fourth Horseman of the Apocalypse? We’ve done Plague, Floods and War. Famine must be drumming its hooves against the stable door. Amid all the dark madness, quite understandably, we have lost sight of problems closer to home. 

A reminder came last week when terms of reference were published for the UK Covid inquiry, which is to be chaired this spring by Lady Hallett, the former Court of Appeal judge. At first glance, the remit seems reasonably broad, but I spy some worrying omissions – such as the effect of lockdown on children and young people. As Robert Halfon, chairman of the education select committee, told the Commons, for the Covid inquiry to only investigate restrictions on school attendance was “like calling a mortuary a ‘negative patients output’”.

Already, it seems clear that the Government would prefer to focus on Covid deaths and the Covid “bereaved”, and avoid painful contemplation of the lockdown victims – that is, those whose mental and physical health, livelihoods and education were damaged by actions taken by ministers, scientists, civil servants and the NHS.

It is far too easy for “the pandemic” to become a catch-all scapegoat for human error. Like those infuriating recorded messages you still get whenever you try to see a GP: “Due to the Coronavirus pandemic, we are planning on stringing out working from home for as long as possible, because, well, it really suits us, actually, so please try to avoid illness or death where possible. If you must see a doctor, make yourself available in a 4.5-hour window (yes, even if you’ve got a job!), when a GP will eventually call you and tell you there are no appointments until April. But do call 111 instead! Alternatively, you may try the surgery again at 8am tomorrow when you can dial our number 73 times and finally be told all appointments for the day are taken. Due to the Coronavirus pandemic, we are experiencing high call volumes. To lose the will to live, please press 1…”

Let’s be clear: the virus is not to blame for GPs failing to see their patients. (Doctors in most other countries never stopped face-to-face appointments.) The virus is not responsible for this week’s devastating news that mental health services received a record 4.3 million referrals last year. The Royal College of Psychiatrists calls it “the biggest hit to mental health in generations”.

The virus is not to blame for the fact that a frantic mum I know, whose 10-year-old says he wants to die, has been told the first appointment that CAMHS (Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services) can offer her son is in three years’ time. That’s three years, not months. 

Lockdown caused, and continues to cause, all of the above. We are now living with the tragic consequences and any inquiry worth its salt must ask some hard questions of the people who did this to us. How dare they?

Writing in these pages on Monday, Matt Hancock, the former health secretary, said with his infallible cheery complacency: “I wouldn’t want to portray the pandemic response as faultless, but we did all we could and constantly tried to learn lessons as we went on.” It’s big of Matt to admit his pandemic response was not faultless. Some might say that allowing thousands of elderly patients to be turfed out of hospital, without testing them first, and putting them back into care homes where Covid spread like a forest fire among the vulnerable elderly was a teeny bit worse than not quite perfect. Let’s see what Lady Hallett thinks.

Hancock is certainly correct to say that the Left’s rejoicing that Boris bungled the Covid response, doing far worse than comparable countries, is unfounded. As the latest data reveal, the UK had lower excess death rates than most other European countries, and England’s death rate was very marginally lower than in Wales and Scotland, who kept draconian restrictions for longer.

Oddly, what Matt doesn’t mention is that our country has ended up with the longest hospital waiting list in the world and 740,000 missed cancer referrals. So what you might call our collateral-damage death rate may soon be beyond horrifying.

Related Posts

Zelensky inspected the site of the missile strike in Dnieper (photo)

In Dnieper, in particular, the locomotive depot was damaged, and a number of infrastructure facilities were destroyed in populated areas of the region. Zelensky visited the Dnipropetrovsk…

Scientists have revealed the origin of the most popular coffee variety: it is more than half a million years old.

The Arabica coffee variety predates any human intervention. The most popular coffee variety is over half a million years old / Photo – depositphotos.com The most popular…

The Netherlands is urgently allocating more than €200 million to help Kyiv: what will the funds be used for?

According to the country’s defense minister, Ukraine needs short-range air defense systems that can be used to combat drone attacks. The Netherlands is urgently allocating more than…

The West’s key ally in the fight against Russian influence in Africa asked the United States to “exit”

Chad has called on the US to withdraw its troops from a military base in the country. African countries are breaking ties with the West / photo…

A giant snake lived in the jungles of India 47 million years ago

Beyond its astonishing length, the ancient snake may tell us more about the evolution of similar giant snakes. Compared to snake species that exist today, V. indicus…

Missile strike on Yuzhny: Russians destroyed grain for Asia and Africa

One of the damaged terminals belongs to the world famous Singaporean company Delta Wilmar. Two terminals in the port of Yuzhny, which specialize in transshipment of agricultural…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *